The student weekly of St. Olaf | Tuesday, September 16, 2014 | Subscribe
ISSUE 119 VOL 7 PUBLISHED 11/4/2005

Letter to the Editor

By Melanie Meinzer
Contributing Writer

Friday, November 4, 2005

We are writing in response to the cartoon that was published on page A5 in the Oct. 28 edition of the Manitou Messenger. The cartoon, “Olaf’s OTHER coming out week,” depicts a young man who is “coming out” as a conservative to a young woman. While the author likely created this cartoon with no malicious intent toward St. Olaf’s GLBT (gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender) community, its message targeted and belittled the significance of, and sentiments behind, National Coming Out Week.

We acknowledge the difficulties and frustrations of being politically or socially conservative at St. Olaf. Despite efforts to create an equal playing field for “intellectual diversity,” many students labeled as “conservative” have been personally attacked for their views, had their door signs vandalized, and no doubt have felt uncomfortable or marginalized in a classroom,or college-sponsored event – just like many GLBT people and their allies.

However, such comparison between the repression of those with conservative political identities and those with GLBT identities becomes offensive and misguided when we consider the extent to which hate crimes and institutionalized discrimination have been and continue to be committed against GLBT people. “Coming out” as a conservative at St. Olaf, or in the broader community, will certainly not keep anyone from serving in the military, getting married, adopting children, receiving medical benefits for loved ones, or obtaining a job. Rather, conservatives enjoy the privilege of controlling all three branches of our government. Celebrating “coming out” as a conservative will be necessary when gays and lesbians control the government and conservatives are forced to fight daily for the dignity, safety and civil liberties of themselves and their families.

The purpose of GLBT Coming Out Week is to support, celebrate and remember those who have “come out” before us. Many GLBT people, such as Brandon Teena and Matthew Shepherd, have been disowned, taunted, tortured, raped or murdered for their courageous acts of coming out. While St. Olaf’s community tends to have a far more tolerant reaction to coming out, the prevalence of St. Olaf students who remain in the closet speaks to the continued difficulty of the act which this week celebrates. Regardless of whether you affirm GLBT identity, please respect the courage of GLBT people and their allies who courageously choose to openly confront the challenges which they encounter.

– Paul Dillon and Megan Remtema GLOW Co-Coordinators

Printer Friendly version of this page Printer friendly version | E-mail a Copy of the Article to a Friend Email this | Write the editors | More articles by Melanie Meinzer

Related Links

More Stories

Page Load: 47 milliseconds