The student weekly of St. Olaf | Thursday, April 24, 2014 | Subscribe
ISSUE 120 VOL 11 PUBLISHED 2/14/2007

Putin chastizes America

By Lisa Gulya
Staff Writer


Wednesday, February 14, 2007

One of our first-day icebreakers in Russian class this semester was answering, “"What should other Americans know about Russia?”" Putin’'s condemnation at the Munich security conference is a another reminder, like the Litvinenko poisoning and Politkovskaya murder, for us to take a closer look at Russia. Who is this chastizing us, and why should we care?

When I was in Russia this fall, I told a Russian journalist that most Americans didn’'t think about Russia as anything more than a mafia haven. The journalist warned me that we Americans should take note of Russia. This weekend, Putin’'s attack was nothing if not attention-getting for Americans.

Putin stuck it to us. And our media response was predictable--op-ed writers across the country threw the accusations of international interference and hegemony right back at him.

Beyond illustrating Putin’'s hypocrisy, some journalists made a more important observation. Putin’'s Middle East tour no doubt partially motivated him to get in a good dig at the United States More importantly, though, his speech illuminates Russian frustration about its diminished international reputation. That frustration is worth noting.

Russia may be diminished in size from the Soviet Union, but it still has arms power, including the newly developing intercontinental ballistic missile, Topol-M. As The Washington Post points out, there are several reasons other than the Topol-M to dissuade us from upsetting Russia including the air defense missiles it has given Iran and its antitank missiles used by Hezbollah against Israel last summer.

And one more weapon the Russian president holds: a 70 percent approval rating. Couple that with a strong desire of the Russian people to regain superpower status, and Putin’'s bravado seems even more natural. As The Washington Post’s David Ignatius points out, Putin’'s “generation of Russians grew up in a country that claimed the status of ‘superpower,’ and they don'’t like being taken for granted.”

Recent poll results reported in the Russian newsweekly Ogoniok confirm that resentment: while 12 percent responded that Russia has never lost superpower status, another 34 percent expressed a desire to regain that status.

In that context, the United States’ tentative response seems prudent in response to a country that has been cut down yet still possesses immense petroleum wealth and a weapons supply that it is willing to share.


Opinions Editor Lisa Gulya is a senior from Fargo, N.D. She majors in English and in Russian language with a concentration in women’s studies.


Printer Friendly version of this page Printer friendly version | E-mail a Copy of the Article to a Friend Email this | Write the editors | More articles by Lisa Gulya

Related Links

More Stories

Page Load: 47 milliseconds